Thursday, June 6, 2024

THE MAN WHO CAME TO DINNER (1941)

 


Directed By: William Keighley 

Written By: Julius J. Epstein & Philip G. Epstein

Based On The Stage Play By: George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart

Cinematography: Tony Gaudio

Editor: Jack Killifer 


Cast: Monty Woolley, Ann Sheridan, Bette Davis, Jimmy Durante, Richard Travis, Billie Burke, Reginald Gardiner, Elisabeth Fraser, Grant Mitchell, Mary Wickes 


Sheridan Whiteside, an eccentric and acid-tongued radio lecturer, is disabled on the doorstep of a prominent Ohio family and must remain confined to the unwilling family's home for a few days. Discovering what he believes to be problems within the household, hatches a plot to fix all of the household's problems. 


Sherry then proceeds to find out that his leg is fine so he bribes the doctor to declare him unfit to leave for a few weeks so he can meddle with the lives of the members of the household. But has he made a mistake?



While you definitely notice the film’s theater origins as a play by George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart. 


The highlights of the movie are the main character of the movie played by Monty Woolley. Even in a film with two female superstars of the time Anne Sheridan and Bettie Davis. He is the one who is given the most screen time and the best laughs.


Ann Sheridan at least gets chances for her character to join in on the comedy. Bettie Davis plays an important character but barely gets anything to really do. As she is more of a straight woman throughout. 


Woolley’s character is acid-tongued and insults almost everyone around him. He is an intellectual snob who believes he is better than everyone. While it is never particularly said he seems to also be homosexual. The film makes it seem that he is different in taste and class than his wealthy benefactors whose house he slips in front of and is forced to put up with him. While they put him up.


Throughout he causes all sorts of trouble for the family particularly the matriarch and in true selfish fashion. When his assistant played by David falls in love. He tries to sabotage it not because he is in love with his assistant but for her companionship. One could see it as he has been made to feel like an outsider all of his life because of his style, intelligence, and decor. 


So now he is taking it out on everyone who is considered normal and hetero to a degree. As no one is safe from his tongue lashings. Most accept them as they aren’t aware they are being insulted, others who do can only bluster as they know they can't do anything about it. Those Who try to verbally spar often lose. Even his accomplices tend to switch sides or he turns on them at least once or twice.


He is technically the villain but also the centerpiece and most interesting character that you end up loving to hate him or hate to love him.


It might as well be a one-man show. As Monty Woolley shines in every scene and takes over. Most characters in this movie talk a mile a minute and so does the action and jokes at times. As it is a kind of screwball comedy. He is the main focus even telegenic the film tries to throw some sight gags and physical comedy in the mix it feels like leftover from the fresh and sharp dialogue. So that anytime it leaves him or focuses on another character. It slows down and becomes a bit dull.


The only other person in the film who truly steals scenes is Jimmy Durante and his antics who come into the film in the third act as another accomplice of Woolley’s He gives the film much-needed energy. As Durante on screen is so energetic it’s like he drank 12 lattes before each take. His appearance is a late great surprise. 


Ultimately the film is entertaining and can see why It’s Considered a classic. Though It’s not as strong as one would hope if it wasn’t for the main role. This film would feel rather basic. It might be the direction or presentation overall. 


Grade: B 

No comments:

Post a Comment